What Counts As Evidence in Social Science?

7554750172_ec0e9d5a1e_o

BQO ROUNDUP

Flickr Duncan Hull (CC)

There’s a huge debate going on in social science right now. The question is simple, and strikes near the heart of all research: What counts as solid evidence?

The answer matters because many disciplines are currently in the midst of a “replication crisis” where even textbook studies aren’t holding up against rigorous retesting. The list includes: ego depletion, the idea that willpower is a finite resource; the facial feedback hypothesis, which suggested if we activate muscles used in smiling, we become happier; and many, many more.

Scientists are now figuring out how to right the ship, to ensure scientific studies published today won’t be laughed at in a few years.

One of the thorniest issues on this question is statistical significance. It’s one of the most influential metrics to determine whether a result is published in a scientific journal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *